N54 VC Scan

N54 Valvecover Scan (stl) 1.0

No permission to download

The Convert

Captain
Jun 4, 2017
1,487
1,053
0
Ride
335
Yeah, I'm in the market for a good handheld 3D scanner, the one I have is utter crap. Their scan looked pretty clean so I though I might ask.
I’m also somewhat in the market. What scanner do you have that you don’t like?
 

doublespaces

Administrator
Oct 18, 2016
9,310
4,342
0
AZ
Ride
2009 E93 335i
From my very basic research it seems this is what I'd consider first:
 

Boorda

Corporal
Jul 15, 2018
145
62
0
45
Royse City, TX
futemire.com
Ride
328xi, 335xi M Sport
From my very basic research it seems this is what I'd consider first:

This is what I was looking at next actually, should have been my first choice. 😕
 

doublespaces

Administrator
Oct 18, 2016
9,310
4,342
0
AZ
Ride
2009 E93 335i
If I could chisle out more time to learn fusion 360 I might invest in something like that. I'd need it to make financial sense.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: The Convert

AWCR1MC

Specialist
Jun 29, 2020
52
32
0
San Francisco, CA
Ride
135i
I tried to go the under $2k mark getting a Structure Sensor and an iPad Pro. I have used Faro scanners before, but $60k is out of my league personally.
I have the structure sensor with an iPad pro and love it. I use it to scan clients homes before I do a 3D render of their new layout. The measurements aren't always as precise as I would like, which would worry me when using it to scan a VC.
 

The Convert

Captain
Jun 4, 2017
1,487
1,053
0
Ride
335
I tried to go the under $2k mark getting a Structure Sensor and an iPad Pro. I have used Faro scanners before, but $60k is out of my league personally.

I’ve used faro as well and totally agree on price.

If I could chisle out more time to learn fusion 360 I might invest in something like that. I'd need it to make financial sense.

Same. I’ve been using Siemens NX for the past 8yrs, but I’ll never be able to afford a seat of that for personal use and I’m no longer with the company I had access to it at.
 
  • Like
Reactions: doublespaces

Boorda

Corporal
Jul 15, 2018
145
62
0
45
Royse City, TX
futemire.com
Ride
328xi, 335xi M Sport
If I could chisle out more time to learn fusion 360 I might invest in something like that. I'd need it to make financial sense.

Fusion 360 is a great product. I've actually been administering Autodesk products where I work for almost 8 years and have had the privilege of using the product. I've been fortunate enough to get a home use license from my company, but I know you can get Fusion at around $500/yr or $60 a month if you dont pay annually.

Fusion 360 Pricing
 

Boorda

Corporal
Jul 15, 2018
145
62
0
45
Royse City, TX
futemire.com
Ride
328xi, 335xi M Sport
I have the structure sensor with an iPad pro and love it. I use it to scan clients homes before I do a 3D render of their new layout. The measurements aren't always as precise as I would like, which would worry me when using it to scan a VC.

It does get me a rough estimate that I can import into CAD as an STL, but the accuracy is just not there where I need it. My other complaint is that it can't seem to find a good way to convert the mesh from triangles to quads which would allow me to convert the scan to a solid CAD models.

....unless you know a better way....
 
  • Like
Reactions: AWCR1MC

The Convert

Captain
Jun 4, 2017
1,487
1,053
0
Ride
335
It does get me a rough estimate that I can import into CAD as an STL, but the accuracy is just not there where I need it. My other complaint is that it can't seem to find a good way to convert the mesh from triangles to quads which would allow me to convert the scan to a solid CAD models.

....unless you know a better way....
Unless I’m mistaken, which is very possible. I haven’t done any work with scan to model in years, but most meshes were used to the create new sketches and models from to create standard radii, chamfers, lengths, etc. if there is better software now, I’d certainly be happy to hear about it.
 

Boorda

Corporal
Jul 15, 2018
145
62
0
45
Royse City, TX
futemire.com
Ride
328xi, 335xi M Sport
Unless I’m mistaken, which is very possible. I haven’t done any work with scan to model in years, but most meshes were used to the create new sketches and models from to create standard radii, chamfers, lengths, etc. if there is better software now, I’d certainly be happy to hear about it.

Fusion 360 can transform meshes into solids... if you can get them into quad meshes first which tend to be more accurate for solid model design.

I have tried a few different softwares to do the conversions but haven't had much luck. Closest I got was by using Blender, but that program has such a learning curve when you're new to it.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: The Convert

AWCR1MC

Specialist
Jun 29, 2020
52
32
0
San Francisco, CA
Ride
135i
It does get me a rough estimate that I can import into CAD as an STL, but the accuracy is just not there where I need it. My other complaint is that it can't seem to find a good way to convert the mesh from triangles to quads which would allow me to convert the scan to a solid CAD models.

....unless you know a better way....

I’ve never tried to convert the mesh since I just use the skp files. They come as a complete 3D model, then I go in and edit them. Only converting I do is skp to dwg for final construction documents.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: The Convert

Boorda

Corporal
Jul 15, 2018
145
62
0
45
Royse City, TX
futemire.com
Ride
328xi, 335xi M Sport
I’ve never tried to convert the mesh since I just use the skp files. They come as a complete 3D model, then I go in and edit them. Only converting I do is skp to dwg for final construction documents.

SKP file, is that a Sketch Up Pro file?
I've never tried that way before.
 

The Convert

Captain
Jun 4, 2017
1,487
1,053
0
Ride
335
I’ve never tried to convert the mesh since I just use the skp files. They come as a complete 3D model, then I go in and edit them. Only converting I do is skp to dwg for final construction documents.
This is very intriguing. Any chance you could do a short video tutorial on this, or instructions and images?