Technical Single High flow catch can system for n54

Oct 24, 2016
1,152
1,202
0
46
Scottsdale, AZ
What’s the point in even talking about it then?
The subject was Vaccum pumps for clearing the crankcase. The stock pump was brought up. We simply said the stock pump pulls no nowhere near enough volume to provide anything useful under boost and mentioned real vacuum pumps need to be used. We mentioned we are running one. See how those two relate, vacuum pump - vacuum pump. Then Tyler asked for full details, we prefer not to share those, Pretty simple stuff.
 

martymil

Major General
Sep 6, 2017
3,331
1,912
0
Down Under
Ride
S65 1m
Until something is ready Chris i'll make my catch can for my car as its going to be more than ample for my needs.

I'm looking forward to seeing your setup once your ready.
 
Oct 24, 2016
1,152
1,202
0
46
Scottsdale, AZ
Until something is ready Chris i'll make my catch can for my car as its going to be more than ample for my needs.

I'm looking forward to seeing your setup once your ready.
This set up is for 100% race cars only. It requires the removal of AC, PS, etc. We have it installed on both our half-mile car and the upcoming drag car. At some point, once we get some new trap speeds at 1/2 mile events, and some ET's we will post up some build notes. Its just a little premature currently. We like to put results before build details.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20190803_0827582.jpg
    IMG_20190803_0827582.jpg
    326.4 KB · Views: 101
Oct 24, 2016
1,152
1,202
0
46
Scottsdale, AZ
Here is a log screenshot on a low boost run from early testing. After dialing the pressure relieves in we have it pulling about 12 in/hg at redline now regardless of boost. At idle it pulls about 5-6 in/HG which is perfect. Run is attached for reference of what kind of power it makes on 10 psi...:tearsofjoy:

Vacuum pump log.jpg

10 PSI.JPG
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: The Convert

WOT808

Specialist
Aug 7, 2017
81
56
25
Ride
E90 335i
Here is a log screenshot on a low boost run from early testing. After dialing the pressure relieves in we have it pulling about 12 in/hg at redline now regardless of boost. At idle it pulls about 5-6 in/HG which is perfect. Run is attached for reference of what kind of power it makes on 10 psi...:tearsofjoy:

I've seen a couple of posts that say the stock PCV system pulls around 30 mbar (1 in/hg) at idle.
What factors lead to 5 - 6 in/hg being your perfect setting?
 

The Convert

Captain
Jun 4, 2017
1,487
1,053
0
Ride
335
I've seen a couple of posts that say the stock PCV system pulls around 30 mbar (1 in/hg) at idle.
What factors lead to 5 - 6 in/hg being your perfect setting?
12in/hg is generally considered to be ideal for reducing windage and reducing blowby while being low enough to not pull air past seals or prevent oiling. I’m sure there are variations from engine to engine, but I’d imagine Tony has played around with his vacuum break to set the highest vacuum he can under full load without causing any seal howling and the 5-6 is where it falls at idle.
 
Oct 24, 2016
1,152
1,202
0
46
Scottsdale, AZ
I've seen a couple of posts that say the stock PCV system pulls around 30 mbar (1 in/hg) at idle.
What factors lead to 5 - 6 in/hg being your perfect setting?
The stock PCV system uses manifold vacuum to pull at idle. That is generally between 15-20 in/hg depending on the vehicle. The factory PCV system restricts this down, and you end up with a small amount of vacuum being pulled. If you go External PCV, plug the head ports, and leave that same 15-20 in/HG unchecked you are pulling vacuum past the seals, and need to use a vacuum relief or metered leak to get it down to a usable level. 5-6 In/HG is a perfect place to be at idle to avoid pulling vacuum past the seals, and also giving enough vacuum to evacuate the crankcase.
 
Oct 24, 2016
1,152
1,202
0
46
Scottsdale, AZ
during WOT it basically prevents oil from being brought into combustion chamber

A vacuum pump isn't used for that.
Hi Chris. A VTT billet vacuum relief valve gets down to 10 in/hg with no shims ... I likely don't understand something, or Tony is addressing this in some other way. Can you clarify for me? Thanks!

Filippo
Can get the vacuum down as low as you want. There is no set level. 10 in/hg is fine if you are running manifold vacuum at idle. You want 5 remove the shims, and trim the spring to get what you want.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Reactions: WOT808 and fmorelli
Oct 24, 2016
1,152
1,202
0
46
Scottsdale, AZ
Yes it is.
That you think a Vacuum pumps main goal to keep oil out of the combustion chamber is your right, it doesn't mean it is correct. The vacuum pump is there to clear the crankcase of crank windage, crankcase pressure from combustion making its way past the rings, etc. This frees up pumping losses and increases the engine efficiency and therefore additional power is usually made. On the other hand. A catch can is designed to keep oil out of the combustion chamber by removing the oil mist from these removed gases before they routed back into the intake tract if you are not going VTA. But we appreciate the opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Convert

The Banshee

Corporal
Nov 18, 2017
175
104
0
Lehigh Valley PA
Ride
2008 335xi coupe 6466 MT
That you think a Vacuum pumps main goal to keep oil out of the combustion chamber is your right, it doesn't mean it is correct. The vacuum pump is there to clear the crankcase of crank windage, crankcase pressure from combustion making its way past the rings, etc. This frees up pumping losses and increases the engine efficiency and therefore additional power is usually made. On the other hand. A catch can is designed to keep oil out of the combustion chamber by removing the oil mist from these removed gases before they routed back into the intake tract if you are not going VTA. But we appreciate the opinion.
I never said it was the main goal so don’t put words in my mouth. You made a statement that is misleading and incorrect in regards to what a vacuum pump does on a racing engine. Maybe you were speaking in terms of n54 only??

I don’t need a lecture on the basics of vacuum pumps as my experience with that goes far beyond the n54 but I do appreciate what you are developing here.
 
Oct 24, 2016
1,152
1,202
0
46
Scottsdale, AZ
We have been building turbos kits in some way shape or form since 1978 when we pulled turbos from aircraft and put them on race cars, boats etc. Just an FYI, If you are here to compare resumes and length of time working on race car things.

What Omar stated is incorrect, what you are stating backing him is inherently incorrect. As I said you can disagree all you would like, it doesn't make you right. No, unfortunately a vacuum pump does not "during WOT it basically prevents oil from being brought into combustion chamber" That is the job of an engine catch can or crankcase filter" The vacuum pump is removing pressure from the bottom of the piston, not the top, it has nothing to do with keeping anything out of the combustion chamber, it has everything to do with keeping things out of the crankcase. Two distinctly different areas of the engine. Crankcase gases are never going to be sucked into the combustion chamber even on a motor with tired rings the combustion process produces much higher pressure, and with poor ring seal, it will pressurize the crankcase. The crankcase will not pressurize the combustion chamber and dilute it with oil. You are perfectly describing the purpose of a catch can again, but hey everyone has their opinions. There are people out there that actually believe the earth is flat, enjoy your holiday sir...:kissingheart:
 
Last edited:
  • Funny
Reactions: The Banshee

martymil

Major General
Sep 6, 2017
3,331
1,912
0
Down Under
Ride
S65 1m
I remember running N/A engines with huge cams back in the late 80 and 90s where vacuum at low engine speeds was pretty much non existent or way to low to operate the brake booster.

What we use to do is get a diesel alternator which had a vacuum pump piggy backed of the back to supply the brakes to operate.

Do you think something like that could be done or run it of the shotgun bracket for street cars and once helix fixes their design.

Is it worth it for a street car to run one ?
 

The Banshee

Corporal
Nov 18, 2017
175
104
0
Lehigh Valley PA
Ride
2008 335xi coupe 6466 MT
We have been building turbos kits in some way shape or form since 1978 when we pulled turbos from aircraft and put them on race cars, boats etc. Just an FYI, If you are here to compare resumes and length of time working on race car things.

What Omar stated is incorrect, what you are stating backing him is inherently incorrect. As I said you can disagree all you would like, it doesn't make you right. No, unfortunately a vacuum pump does not "during WOT it basically prevents oil from being brought into combustion chamber" That is the job of an engine catch can or crankcase filter" The vacuum pump is removing pressure from the bottom of the piston, not the top, it has nothing to do with keeping anything out of the combustion chamber, it has everything to do with keeping things out of the crankcase. Two distinctly different areas of the engine. Crankcase gases are never going to be sucked into the combustion chamber even on a motor with tired rings the combustion process produces much higher pressure, and with poor ring seal, it will pressurize the crankcase. The crankcase will not pressurize the combustion chamber and dilute it with oil. You are perfectly describing the purpose of a catch can again, but hey everyone has their opinions. There are people out there that actually believe the earth is flat, enjoy your holiday sir...:kissingheart:
Tony, If you think it is not possible to blow oil into the combustion chamber with weak rings and excessive crank case pressure then you should probably go back to selling sneakers. I’m out.
 

The Convert

Captain
Jun 4, 2017
1,487
1,053
0
Ride
335
Tony, If you think it is not possible to blow oil into the combustion chamber with weak rings and excessive crank case pressure then you should probably go back to selling sneakers. I’m out.
The only possible way your crankcase could be pressurized above the pressure in your cylinders is if your pcv system were totally f*cked, you were running insane boost pressures, you were at bdc, and even then at worst would be at a the same psi on both sides of the piston.
I don’t see any scenario where you could put more pressure in the case than the cylinder.
 

Omar@VaderSolutions

Lieutenant
Premium Vendor
Oct 19, 2016
535
409
25
NY & AZ
vadersolution.com
Ride
N54 135i & N54 335i
We have been building turbos kits in some way shape or form since 1978 when we pulled turbos from aircraft and put them on race cars, boats etc. Just an FYI, If you are here to compare resumes and length of time working on race car things.

What Omar stated is incorrect, what you are stating backing him is inherently incorrect. As I said you can disagree all you would like, it doesn't make you right. No, unfortunately a vacuum pump does not "during WOT it basically prevents oil from being brought into combustion chamber" That is the job of an engine catch can or crankcase filter" The vacuum pump is removing pressure from the bottom of the piston, not the top, it has nothing to do with keeping anything out of the combustion chamber, it has everything to do with keeping things out of the crankcase. Two distinctly different areas of the engine. Crankcase gases are never going to be sucked into the combustion chamber even on a motor with tired rings the combustion process produces much higher pressure, and with poor ring seal, it will pressurize the crankcase. The crankcase will not pressurize the combustion chamber and dilute it with oil. You are perfectly describing the purpose of a catch can again, but hey everyone has their opinions. There are people out there that actually believe the earth is flat, enjoy your holiday sir...:kissingheart:


oil sneaking through worn rings happens... vacuum pump helps prevent it
it also helps seals the ring to prevent pressure from combustion chamber to to enter crank case
helps clear crank from any windage

the fact that you said i was wrong is wrong, it was just an incomplete answer
 
Oct 24, 2016
1,152
1,202
0
46
Scottsdale, AZ
I remember running N/A engines with huge cams back in the late 80 and 90s where vacuum at low engine speeds was pretty much non existent or way to low to operate the brake booster.

What we use to do is get a diesel alternator which had a vacuum pump piggy backed of the back to supply the brakes to operate.

Do you think something like that could be done or run it of the shotgun bracket for street cars and once helix fixes their design.

Is it worth it for a street car to run one ?
The vacuum pump required is LARGE to move the volume needed. A shotgun bracket is not going to work. Much too small. Look up the GZ pumps, it's what we use. Not cheap, not small, but most race car things are neither. Whats the point of going through all the work of adding the small vacuum pump if it doesn't move enough volume to actually clear the crankcase. The N54 makes big power it needs a full size vacuum pump if you want to realize the full benefits. Getting one to fit as akin to fitting 10lbs of shit in a 5lb bag, and once it's on, getting it dialed in was another adventure unto itself